Shortly after waking up this morning, I realized I didn't have Kelly Clarkson's most recent album, All I Ever Wanted.
"So what?"
Well let me just sum things up by saying I was an instant and loyal fan from her first audition on American Idol and her albums are the only albums I've actually gone to the store and bought in the past 7 years.
Okay, so as I was saying, I was quite shocked this morning when I came to this realization. I mean I know WHY I hadn't gone out to get her album as soon as I first heard a leaked recording of "My Life Would Suck Without You" - I absolutely loathed the song. And if that was the direction this album was going in, there was certainly no way I would enjoy it. The way MLWSWY is so obviously a grossly-overcompensating effort to "get back on track" after Kelly's generally unsupported detour with My December from her pop-hit album Breakaway, the way that is so glaringly obvious is almost insulting to Kelly's artistry and to her fans' intelligence. I mean honestly, from the intro base guitar to the tempo of the song to the low-register verse vocal to the sudden transition to "soaring" vocal in the chorus, MLWSWY sounds an unmistakable hell of a lot like "Since U Been Gone" (I still lament mildly about the use of letter-in-replacement-of-word in that song title). But hello - that's like saying "Hey Michael Jackson, "Thriller" was a huge hit so let's try to make another song almost exactly like it." Beside the insultingly obvious similarity and emulation between the songs: 1) MLWSWY's chorus melody is about as imaginative and dynamic as a one-note trumpet solo - seriously inferior to that of "Since U Been Gone;" 2) What the *#$% is up with all the vocal synthesizing? Kelly, I cannot believe you were okay with that. Not only do your vocals not NEED that, your vocals sound so much better WITHOUT it.
Just plain insulting.
Her second single, "I Do Not Hook Up," thank god, was loads better. Atleast there's a melody in there that spans more than 4 consecutive notes.
And so - I downloaded the rest of her album this morning to see if perhaps there were more songs like "I Do Not Hook Up" that I would find enjoyable. And what is the first song I happen to play!?!?!?! "Tip of My Tongue." Nothing on the album has thusfar infuriated me so quickly as the cheap, pop-R&B synthetic beat intro that sounds 90% exactly like that of Gwen Stefani's "Holla Back Girl." ARE YOU KIDDING ME!?!?! I don't know who I should be angry at - Kelly for not holding up to who she is as an artist or her producers for trying to make her into something she most certainly is not. Kelly Clarkson is pop-rock. Kelly Clarkson is not Gwen Stefani or Jordin Sparks ("Impossible") or Britney Spears ("If I Can't Have You") or Leona Lewis ("Already Gone"). Trust me, it did not require any effort whatsoever on my part to think of these analogies - I heard each song and immediately thought it sounded like a song specifically by those artists.
Now let us turn our attention to another dimension of the album - its cover. In her blog, Kelly says, "they have definitely photo-shopped the crap out of me but i don’t care haha! whoever she is, she looks great ha!" Clearly. Although I do not agree with the latter assertion. She's a beautiful girl and she looked just fine on her previous albums without the help of Brightness/Contrast-abuse and Sparkle-shaped paintbrush. Not to mention the flat, uncreative, tri-chromatic background that looks like it was slapped together in 30 seconds.
So, the album All I Ever Wanted fails on account of originality, artist identity, vocal credibility, and even visual aestheticism.
Whew. End of rant.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
agreed with all of it :-)
ReplyDelete